Zooks and Yooks and Vax Attacks
The Butter Battle Book
On your quest through tall tales in all your best books. You’ll find nothing better than the Zooks and the Yooks. “Who are they?” You may say, as you wave me away. I’ll answer, dear reader, but please sit and please stay. I’m not sure how he keeps it up. Somehow, some way, Dr. Seuss delivers a fable; a proverb; a prophecy; with clarity and zeal, and in anapestic tetrameter. For those of you that crossed paths with Dr Seuss only decades ago, let me take a moment to dust off this cover with you. The Zooks are a people that butter their bread butter-side-up. The Yooks, instead, apply their spread butter-side-down. From this innocuous difference brews a distaste for one another that far outstrips these humble beginnings. There is a wall between the two clans that is patrolled by a Yook with a switch. His Zook counterpart bests his switch with a slingshot. The arms race has begun. Step by step, the conflict rises in pitch until the final crescendo: each patrolman is armed with a world-ending bomb. The curtain falls at this impasse, attended by the ominous phrase: “We will have to wait and see.”
In this thinly-veiled parable of the Cold War, published in 1984, we are shown two peoples with nominally the same values. Their most important difference is largely irrelevant. And yet, that’s exactly how humans define their outgroups.
Ingroup, Outgroup
In the words of Henry Tajfel (1974), a social psychologist known for his work on prejudice:
“[I]n order for the members of an ingroup to be able to hate or dislike an outgroup, or to discriminate against it, they must first have acquired a sense of belonging to a group which is clearly distinct from the one they hate, dislike or discriminate against.”
And so we fixate on the differences between groups in order to draw clean borders around them. Psychologically, evolutionarily, we are programmed to operate in a group of no more than fifty people. We can trust easier within our group, which greatly facilitates cooperation (see Hamburg et al, 1975, “Group Size and Cooperation”). In contrast, If we trust too widely we may be taken advantage of.
And so we seek out these differences and classify others into being “with me” or “against me.” In times of struggle for survival this was a useful thing to do. In today’s world these reactions may be hurting more than helping. At the same time, the increase of this kind of reaction may very well be a response to external threats. More people feel like we are in a time of struggle for existence due to the climate crisis, growing income inequality, and a pandemic (just as a short list).
Actively Open-Minded Thinking
Under duress we fall back on our more primitive instincts. Our nervous systems are keyed up, ready to react. Our focus narrows, and we become hyper alert. We lose our capacity for open minded thinking.
“Actively Open-Minded Thinking” or AOT, is an attempt to quantify how open-minded a person is; how able they are to gain a breadth of information about a topic, including information that conflicts with their previously held beliefs.
AOT has been shown to correlate with skill in estimation tasks (Haran et al., 2013). By being open minded and seeking out more information, we can reason better under uncertainty.
The question of the day seems to be whether to be vaccinated or not. This is an estimation task under uncertainty. Unfortunately, many people in Canada (and especially in my home in the Kootenays) feel under duress and have lost their powers of open-minded thinking. I would argue that I’ve seen this from both sides of the debate; however, the most vociferous views come from the extreme anti-vax camp.
So how do we regain our calm, and open our minds back up to the possibility of learning? We’ll return to the question of “calm” in the section “But What if it’s Us?”. For now let’s engage with the definition of AOT. In the following set of questions, rank yourself from 1 (completely disagree) to 5 (completely agree). The scale on questions 3, 5, 7, and 8 is reversed. Hooray, a mid-article questionnaire!
(1) Willingness to be convinced by opposing arguments is a sign of good character.
(2) People should take into consideration evidence that goes against conclusions they favor.
(3) Being undecided or unsure is the result of muddled thinking.
(4) People should revise their conclusions in response to relevant new information.
(5) Changing your mind is a sign of weakness.
(6) People should search actively for reasons why they might be wrong.
(7) It is OK to ignore evidence against your established beliefs.
(8) It is important to be loyal to your beliefs even when evidence is brought to bear against them.
(9) There is nothing wrong with being undecided about many issues.
(10) When faced with a puzzling question, we should try to consider more than one possible answer before reaching a conclusion
The higher your score the more open-minded you are.
I especially want to highlight (3). Do you believe being undecided means you have muddled thinking? I’ve been asked what my “stance” is on Covid. There is some pressure to answer such questions… even if one does’t have a "stance." Moreover, with our online selves on public display, there is pressure to present a cohesive stance to the world, rather than admit our indecision.
I like to consider questions like this as if I were a small democracy unto myself (a la Mark Manson in his piece: “What is Wisdom”). I have lots of beliefs and considerations that come to bear on a topic as wide as Covid. I can understand a bit of disease spread from my time studying mathematical epidemiology in grad school. I can understand the fear of the unknown. I can understand the feeling of being left behind by a system that doesn’t seem to care about the “little guy.” I can believe there are bad actors in almost every facet of human endeavour (in big pharma, politics, working at the restaurants I frequent, and the folks I pass on the street). And yet, I believe most humans are doing the best they can with what they’ve got and do act with the good of others at heart.
So I don’t have a “stance” on covid. That’s a terrible question - ask a better question. I have an internal democracy weighing many factors. And when it’s time to act (like getting a vaccine), I do so with this democracy playing in the background. And I could be wrong. I also hope and allow for others to have their own internal democracy.
Instead of 7 billion internal democracies, we have lost large swaths of humanity to dogmatic beliefs that they had no part in creating. These ideas prey on our weaknesses. They hijack our capability to bring our internal democracy to session.
How did this come to pass? Is there a nefarious plot pushing society further along this road, or is it merely human nature at play? Who’s fault is this?
It’s all the fault of politicians
Could they be the ones benefiting, and perhaps be the ones propelling us towards a divide?
US senators spend more time on divisive issues when they are up for election (“Elections and Divisiveness: Theory and Evidence” Ash et al., 2017). This helps voters know if they identify a candidate as being in their group, and can therefore be trusted. One of the most pernicious aspects of political campaigns in the modern era is that a candidate no longer has to identify with just one group. Through targeted advertising, a single candidate can claim to be a part of many different groups.
The issues that signal a candidate being in-group have to appear important, but really they could be as trivial as how you butter your bread. In fact, even liking the same kind of paintings provides the basis for an in group (“Experiments in Intergroup Discrimination,” Hafjel, 1970.). Once the group is established, people will willingly ignore evidence from experts in deference to opinions from non-experts within their group. Trump performed a masterclass in this, and now nobody believes anything anymore, but I suppose that’s a whole other can of worms.
So yes - some politicians gain from, and some politicians engender, divisiveness.
It’s all the fault of social media
A generation ago, you talked to your neighbours and you talked to your family - even if they disagreed with you. You got inoculated with a whole host of new ideas. Your media was in print and on the television.
Now, we customize our friend list. Or rather, the passive features of social media upvote the posts that we subconsciously hover over longer, and downvote the posts we quickly scroll past. Our knee jerk reactions are fed back to ourselves faster than we are aware of them. And the result is a kind of sycophantic echo-chamber where we are always right. And our intellectual immune systems are at their weakest.
Yes, social media plays an important role in this divide.
It’s all the fault of the uber-rich
In times of stress and lack of control we purchase more. The poor and middle class expend their meager resources trying to regain a sense of control. The capitalist machine tells you to spend more to fill the holes punched in you by that self-same machine.
If you happen to have been born into the right family, in the right place, at the right time, with the right color skin, the right genitalia, and the right predilection for other genitalia, then the machine works tirelessly to help you profit. Otherwise... not so much
Amazon did pretty well in 2020, and the uber-rich do play a role in this divide.
But what if it’s us?
What if the divisiveness we see is not ultimately foisted upon us from the outside, but an ugly aspect from inside? What if this ugliness is the collective shadow self of our culture, and present in each of us as individuals. What if the Zooks are indeed, just like the Yooks - with deep fears and flaws, but ultimately trying to do their best for themselves and their community? Well that would be… harder to stomach.
What is the “shadow-self?” It’s all those parts of you and me that we have a hard time accepting. It’s the shadow self that reacts before thinking. And it may often be hard to realize it’s there. Carl Jung introduced the shadow self in 1951, following the second world war; a natural setting to wrestle with such ideas. Were Nazis really just horrible people, or rather were they just like us in many ways: with great propensity to do both good and bad acts? The Zooks and the Yooks may have been analogues for the US and the USSR in the cold war, but they’re worth thinking about any time there’s a “bad guy” entering the discussion.
Check out “Carl Jung and the Shadow: The Ultimate Guide to the Dark Side” for an introduction, including these examples of shadow behaviour: 1. A tendency to harshly judge others, especially if that judgment comes on an impulse. 2. Pointing out one’s own insecurities as flaws in another. 3. A quick temper with people in subordinate positions of power. 4. Frequently playing the “victim” of every situation. 5. A willingness to step on others to achieve one’s own ends. 6. Unacknowledged biases and prejudices. 7. A messiah complex. The next time you are confronted with a Covid-related debate or say… a federal election here in Canada, ask yourself if either of the sides is perpetrating these shadow behaviours.
Of all the content I’ve imbibed over Covid, the anti-vax, anti-mask camp uses the word “fear” the most; and often in the context of accusing people who are in line with government regulations: “I don’t live in fear, so I won’t get the vaccine;” “I’m not getting the vaccine, because I’m not a sheep. I think for myself;” “I do my own research and make up my own mind, not like the rest of these idiots;” etc. They spit on employees at our grocery stores for doing their job. They complain their rights are being taken away in analogies to Nazi Germany.
These people are terrified, and projecting it on the rest of our community. They pretty much tick all 7 examples of shadow behaviour.
Plenty of the pro-vaccine folks are also terrified. We are in a complicated time, and the desire to simplify it is compelling. “If those selfish people would just get vaccinated, we would get back to normal;” “Covidiots;” etc. The fear comes out as anger against the perceived enemy, the other, the outgroup. Our minds crave simplicity - and having a complex internal democracy is anything but - so it takes effort to resist being overly reductive.
Where do we go from here?
This all seems like an impossibly large problem to tackle. What can I do now?
1. Avoid consuming manipulative content. That means more reading, more listening, more grappling with ideas that are uncomfortable, and less YouTube sensationalism. Our "News" feeds are not News.
2. Tune in to the emotional words being used in an argument - especially if they don’t need to be there. If one political party is talking about another’s fiscal record, do they provide some data or just claim the other is “untrustworthy,” “irresponsible,” or “dangerous.”
3. When you are confronted by some angry person with beliefs you don’t hold - remember they are hurting. Their anger indicates that’s exactly the time they need the most compassion. Don’t write off a Yook, just because you’re a Zook.
5. Engage with your shadow.* Our cultural divide is the sum and synergy of many divides within each of us. Perhaps it sounds too naive and hopeful - but heal yourself and see what a wonder it does for those around you.
6. Go vote on September 20th! *This can mean different things to different people, depending on how much you've already delved into these things. One of my first steps was to focus on that time between stimulus and response. I'd get annoyed/upset by something and I would react quickly. At first it didn't really seem like there was any time there at all (but there is). By making that time longer it gave me more time to choose how to react. I now feel that gap in time is the essence of being in control of your life. That time is also there for you to wonder about why you had such a strong reaction. Rather than turning away from it, you can turn towards it. Getting pissed at something is now a way in to this work, and I get weirdly excited about it.



Comments
Post a Comment